The
Fifa World Cup is the most highly attended sporting event in the world (
3.18 million in South Africa) which makes the host country responsible for
many aspects of the tourism involved. One of the problems that arose when
Qatar was being considered to host the World Cup was that they would have to
build many stadiums to hold all of the games, but what should be most important
is the safety of everyone involved. A recurring theme has emerged since
the Athens Olympics concerning
the influx of tourists attracting human
traffickers, therefore an important question today is how will the 2014 World
Cup in Brazil have an effect on the country's human trafficking
situation. Although it is debatable whether large sporting events affect
the amount of human trafficking in an area, if the 2014 Fifa World Cup does
affect human trafficking in Brazil it will be in exploited sex workers.

Although
Brazil has one of the worst statistics for human trafficking, its major human
trafficking industry will not be directly affected by the
world cup. According to Kevin Bales in his book Disposable
People, Brazil's
part in the slave trade is much darker than that of the United States, and that
the abolishment of slavery in 1888 may have not affected the vast remote
regions of Brazil where there was little enforcement; consequentially this has
created an environment where slavery, or human trafficking can easily flourish. Bales demonstrates that rapid
economic growth in the 1960's and 1970's lead to a recession in the 1980's.
50,000 of 156,000,000 Brazilians own almost
everything while 4,000,000 people own 3 percent of the land.
Kevin Bales has demonstrated that when
poverty is extreme people are willing to take more extreme risks to make money
in order to sufficiently live.
Bales
research shows that Brazil's largest human trafficking business is charcoal
manufacturing in places where deforestation is occurring.
However, the charcoal business will not be
majorly affected by the influx of tourists.
Sex
trafficking is a form of human trafficking defined as:
the recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of persons, by means of the threat or use of force or other forms of coercion, of abduction, of fraud, of deception, of the abuse of power or of a position of vulnerability or of the giving or receiving of payments or benefits to achieve the consent of a person having control over another person, for the purpose of exploitation. It is
important to note
that sex trafficking is a different than prostitution.
Prostitution or sex work
is legal in Brazil as long as no third party benefits from it, or as long as the sex worker is 18 or older. Because
the sale of sex is legal in Brazil, the country is seen as a sex destination.
As a result, there is a large demand for sex
workers.
The United Nations estimates that approximately 500,000 children are exploited in domestic prostitution
in Brazil.
The law stating that children
younger than 18 cannot be sex workers determines those 500,000 children to be
victims of human trafficking.
Therefore,
if the influx of people in Brazil creates an increased demand for sex workers
in which the current supply cannot meet, then the Brazilian sex industry can
increase its supply in two ways.
The
first is by having consenting adults become sex workers without the threat of
violence or coercion.
The second is by committing
atrocities in forcing adults or children (even if they do consent to it) into
the sex industry.
Forced
labor is a major problem in Brazil, however, he only form of human trafficking that can be directly affected by the
World Cup and the tourism it attracts is sex trafficking. The questions then raised are: 1) does the
tourism associated with sporting events create a larger demand in the sex
industry 2) if the demand is greater because of sporting events does the
Brazilian sex industry already have enough supply 3) if the current supply of
sex workers in Brazil cannot meet the larger demand created by the World Cup
will it lead to sex trafficking or an increase in legal sex workers?
impacted by the World Cup is small.
I thought this was an interesting post that raises some questions about the ethics of these large sporting events. I know that, historically, cities that have hosted the Olympics almost always come away from the event economically disadvantaged. One question I have is whether or not construction will play a role in human trafficking. You stated that Qatar had issues surrounding their supply of labor. Does Brazil currently have the infrastructure to host this event? Will Brazil need to build other stadiums as well? As far as sex trafficking goes, it seems unlikely that tourism, albeit a particularly large amount, would have an effect on the domestic sex trafficking industry. I'm sure that there will be numerous people taking advantage of the enslaved but will there be a growth? One concern I have is the immeasurably of this hypothesis. How are you going to go about determining the impact? I would definitely look into the labor Brazil will have to provide for the events and the origins of this large migrant labor force. Brazil will have to import labor from abroad or within the country. It seems that this opens up the possibility for labor trafficking. I also wonder what the enforcement is like for the domestic sex industry. Does Brazil (like the legal sex trade in Japan and the Netherlands) have enforcement's regarding foreigners participating in the sex trade?
ReplyDeleteUntil reading this post, it had never occurred to me that sex- trafficking and sporting events could be so closely related. Now, however, it seems obvious. What I would like to better understand is how the data used to create the statics about the increase in sex-trafficking due to the influx of tourists is being gathered and measured. Is there concrete evidence that sporting events cause an increase in tracking, or is this just a hypothesis?
ReplyDeleteThis is a new observation to the issue of sex trafficking, and it seems to make a lot of sense. Not too many people realize that sex trafficking would be an issue during major sporting events such as the World Cup. The advantage of tourist coming from different countries would spark a rise of attaining customers in the city where the sporting event is taking place. From these observations we can see the dangers of this for those who are being trafficked. Are there any ways we can prevent this/educate those who are traveling to major sporting events to notice this?
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThe fact that you mentioned that prostitution is legal in Brazil is a very interesting fact because sex trafficking is so closely related to prostitution. Brazil should make prostitution illegal at any age, who is to say a little make up won't make a 14 year old look like an 18 year old. The percentage of sex trafficking going on in Brazil would decrease if a law was passed against prostitution. Do you think it would be a great idea to pass this law or do you think it would create more of an uproar in the sex trafficking industry?
ReplyDelete